Skip to Navigation
TV Video Library: Interviews and Video Clips – Archive of American Television
  • A program of the Television Academy Foundation

Capturing Television History, One Voice At A Time

Home

Judith Crist

Film Critic

"To hell with the novel, to hell with the play, I was going to become a movie critic."

About This Interview

In her four-hour Archive interview, film critic Judith Crist (1922-2012) recounts her early fascination with books and movies. She talks about pursuing a career in journalism and landing her dream job as a film critic for the New York Herald Tribune. She describes how a newspaper strike in 1962 led to her stint as a movie reviewer on WABC-TV.  She also discusses how her scathing review of Cleopatra led to industry notoriety. Crist then speaks of her role as possibly the first regular network movie reviewer on television, as the film critic for the Today show in the 1960s and '70s. She describes the format of her reviews, the film selection process, and her ability to speak extemporaneously on camera. She then talks about her subsequent reviewing on WOR-TV.  Additionally, she chronicles her long tenure as the critic for TV Guide, her appearance in Woody Allen's Stardust Memories, and meeting and befriending legendary film director Federico Fellini. Karen Herman conducted the interview on February 24, 2006 in New York, NY.

Related To This Video

  • Shows
  • People
  • Topics
  • Professions

Shows

  • Academy Awards, The
  • Law & Order
  • Today

People

  • Phyllis Diller
  • Hugh Downs
  • Roger Ebert
  • Reuven Frank
  • Cliff Robertson
  • Bob Smith
  • Barbara Walters
  • Dick Wolf

Topics

  • Creative Influences and Inspiration
  • Diversity in Television
  • Women

Professions

  • Hosts
  • Journalists & News Producers
YouTube video player - HTML5 compatible.
  • Highlights
  • Interview
  • Shows
  • People
  • Topics
  • Genres
  • Professions

Highlights

  • Judith Crist on her early love of films <br/>Judith Crist on her early love of films
    Clip begins at: 16:20, Duration: 01m 03s
  • Judith Crist on Al Morgan inviting her to be movie critic for <i>Today</i>Judith Crist on Al Morgan inviting her to be movie critic for Today
    Clip begins at: 22:03, Duration: 05m 08s
  • Judith Crist on TV Guide asking her to become a critic for the publicationJudith Crist on TV Guide asking her to become a critic for the publication
    Clip begins at: 20:08, Duration: 01m 12s
  • Judith Crist on calling herself a journalistic reviewer <br/>Judith Crist on calling herself a journalistic reviewer
    Clip begins at: 08:53, Duration: 03m 45s
  • Judith Crist on Roger Ebert telling her she was his inspirationJudith Crist on Roger Ebert telling her she was his inspiration
    Clip begins at: 22:39, Duration: 01m 02s

Interview

  • Part 1
  • On her childhood and early influences; on wanting to be a novelist when she was younger; on her early love of films
    Clip begins at: 0:0
  • On policies regarding children attending movies when she was growing up; on favorite film memories
    Clip begins at: 17:23
  • Part 2
  • On remembering watching the film "The Sign of the Cross"; on critics she admired and how she became a film critic
    Clip begins at: 0:0
  • On wanting to attend journalism school; on getting a teaching fellowship at the State College of Washington and meeting a lot of non-New Yorkers and non-elites; on returning to Columbia to do her M.A. and working at the New York Herald Tribune
    Clip begins at: 11:27
  • On reviewing plays; on working with critic Walter Kerr
    Clip begins at: 20:49
  • Part 3
  • On beginning to write film and television critics; on not having her own TV set; on becoming Editor of the Arts for the paper and appearing on television
    Clip begins at: 0:0
  • On her early television appearances; on memories of appearing on Today; on working with Howard Cosell; on officially becoming a movie critic
    Clip begins at: 13:54
  • On Al Morgan inviting her to be movie critic for Today
    Clip begins at: 22:03
  • Part 4
  • On her appearances on Today; on makeup she and Barbara Walters wore on the show; on working with the anchors on Today
    Clip begins at: 0:0
  • On reviewing "Cleopatra" and not enjoying Elizabeth Taylor's performance; on becoming a national figure for that review; on lectures
    Clip begins at: 12:35
  • On TV Guide asking her to become a critic for the publication; on critiquing movies for television
    Clip begins at: 19:15
  • On B-roll photos from her career
    Clip begins at: 22:21
  • Part 5
  • On her tenure at TV Guide and differences between critiquing films vs. television; on reviewing TV movies; on handwriting letters to people
    Clip begins at: 0:0
  • On reviewing "Doctor Zhivago"; on writing for TV Guide
    Clip begins at: 13:15
  • On her time as a film critic on Today; on typical production on the show and how films were selected for review; on reviewing "A Hard Day's Night"
    Clip begins at: 21:34
  • Part 6
  • On the format of her reviews on television; on wearing wigs on Today; on calling herself a journalistic reviewer
    Clip begins at: 0:0
  • On encountering filmmakers and running film weekends; on getting to know Steven Spielberg, Woody Allen, Bette Davis, and Federico Fellini; on leaving Today and being on a Pulitzer Prize Selection Committee
    Clip begins at: 12:38
  • Part 7
  • On serving on a Pulitzer Prize Selection Committee; on returning to television on WOR TV; on meeting Phyllis Diller and other women in television
    Clip begins at: 0:0
  • On not watching today's critics; on today's ratings systems; on the theater-going experience; on getting recognized and questions people ask her
    Clip begins at: 09:16
  • On her opinion of the Academy Awards; on appearing in Woody Allen's "Stardust Memories"
    Clip begins at: 21:13
  • Part 8
  • On "Stardust Memories" contd.; on not encountering sexism as a film critic
    Clip begins at: 0:0
  • On her greatest achievement; on how she'd like to be remembered
    Clip begins at: 18:40
  • On B-roll photos from her career
    Clip begins at: 28:10

Shows

  • Academy Awards, The
    • Judith Crist on her opinion of the Academy Awards
      Clip begins at: 21:13, Duration: 02m 31s
  • Law & Order
    • Judith Crist on reviewing a pivotal episode of Law & Order dealing with the bombing of an abortion clinic
      Clip begins at: 11:02, Duration: 02m 13s
  • Today
    • Judith Crist on memories of appearing on Today
      Clip begins at: 17:28, Duration: 00m 56s
    • Judith Crist on Al Morgan inviting her to be movie critic for Today
      Clip begins at: 22:03, Duration: 06m 27s
    • Judith Crist on her appearances on Today
      Clip begins at: 00:00, Duration: 12m 35s
    • Judith Crist on reviewing "Cleopatra" and not enjoying Elizabeth Taylor's performance
      Clip begins at: 12:35, Duration: 06m 40s
    • Judith Crist on her time as a film critic on Today
      Clip begins at: 21:34, Duration: 08m 30s
    • Judith Crist on the format of her reviews on television; on wearing wigs and who her audience was
      Clip begins at: 01:32, Duration: 07m 21s
    • Judith Crist on interviewing Federico Fellini on Today
      Clip begins at: 20:30, Duration: 05m 43s
    • Judith Crist on why she left Today
      Clip begins at: 26:13, Duration: 01m 33s

People

  • Woody Allen
    • Judith Crist on getting to know Steven Spielberg and Woody Allen
      Clip begins at: 15:34, Duration: 02m 29s
    • Judith Crist on appearing in Woody Allen's "Stardust Memories"
      Clip begins at: 23:44, Duration: 05m 26s
    • Judith Crist on Woody Allen's "Stardust Memories" contd.
      Clip begins at: 00:00, Duration: 06m 16s
  • Howard Cosell
    • Judith Crist on working with Howard Cosell
      Clip begins at: 18:28, Duration: 01m 30s
  • Bosley Crowther
    • Judith Crist on how she became a film critic
      Clip begins at: 05:14, Duration: 05m 05s
  • Bette Davis
    • Judith Crist on being on a panel with Bette Davis
      Clip begins at: 18:03, Duration: 02m 27s
  • Phyllis Diller
    • Judith Crist on meeting Phyllis Diller
      Clip begins at: 04:40, Duration: 00m 42s
  • Hugh Downs
    • Judith Crist on working with Hugh Downs on Today
      Clip begins at: 04:22, Duration: 00m 32s
  • Roger Ebert
    • Judith Crist on Roger Ebert telling her she was his inspiration
      Clip begins at: 22:39, Duration: 01m 02s
  • Federico Fellini
    • Judith Crist on interviewing Federico Fellini on Today
      Clip begins at: 20:30, Duration: 05m 43s
  • Reuven Frank
    • Judith Crist on NBC News' Reuven Frank
      Clip begins at: 10:47, Duration: 01m 48s
  • William Link and Richard Levinson
    • Judith Crist on Levinson and Link supporting her
      Clip begins at: 08:26, Duration: 00m 39s
  • Al Morgan
    • Judith Crist on Al Morgan inviting her to be movie critic for Today
      Clip begins at: 22:03, Duration: 06m 27s
    • Judith Crist on Al Morgan asking her to join Today
      Clip begins at: 08:24, Duration: 02m 23s
  • Dorothy Parker
    • Judith Crist on how she'd like to be remembered
      Clip begins at: 25:12, Duration: 02m 48s
  • Cliff Robertson
    • Judith Crist on a set visit with Cliff Robertson on a children's show
      Clip begins at: 05:32, Duration: 00m 25s
  • Budd Schulberg
    • Judith Crist on NBC's producer Budd Shulberg
      Clip begins at: 11:39, Duration: 00m 56s
  • Gene Shalit
    • Judith Crist on NBC News' Reuven Frank and critic Gene Shalit
      Clip begins at: 09:52
  • Bob Smith
    • Judith Crist on Bob Smith making her wigs for Today
      Clip begins at: 02:27, Duration: 02m 40s
  • Steven Spielberg
    • Judith Crist on getting to know Steven Spielberg and Woody Allen
      Clip begins at: 15:34, Duration: 02m 29s
  • Elizabeth Taylor
    • Judith Crist on reviewing "Cleopatra" and not enjoying Elizabeth Taylor's performance
      Clip begins at: 12:35, Duration: 06m 40s
  • Barbara Walters
    • Judith Crist on makeup she and Barbara Walters wore on Today
      Clip begins at: 03:20, Duration: 01m 02s
    • Judith Crist on working with Barbara Walters on Today
      Clip begins at: 06:09, Duration: 02m 15s
  • Dick Wolf
    • Judith Crist on reviewing a pivotal episode of Law & Order dealing with the bombing of an abortion clinic
      Clip begins at: 11:02, Duration: 02m 13s

Topics

  • Creative Influences and Inspiration
    • Judith Crist on Roger Ebert telling her she was his inspiration
      Clip begins at: 22:39, Duration: 01m 02s
  • Historic Events and Social Change > Diversity in Television
    • Judith Crist on Al Morgan of Today being a big supporter of women
      Clip begins at: 27:11, Duration: 01m 19s
    • Judith Crist on why she left Today and feeling the decision to let her go was sexist
      Clip begins at: 26:13, Duration: 01m 33s
    • Judith Crist on getting to know women in television
      Clip begins at: 05:22, Duration: 03m 54s
    • Judith Crist on not encountering sexism in the television industry
      Clip begins at: 06:16, Duration: 12m 24s
  • Historic Events and Social Change > Diversity in Television > Women
    • Judith Crist on Al Morgan of Today being a big supporter of women
      Clip begins at: 27:11, Duration: 01m 19s
    • Judith Crist on why she left Today and feeling the decision to let her go was sexist
      Clip begins at: 26:13, Duration: 01m 33s
    • Judith Crist on getting to know women in television
      Clip begins at: 05:49, Duration: 03m 27s
    • Judith Crist on not encountering sexism in the television industry
      Clip begins at: 06:16, Duration: 12m 24s

Genres

  • News and Documentary
    • Judith Crist on Al Morgan inviting her to be movie critic for Today
      Clip begins at: 22:03, Duration: 06m 27s
    • Judith Crist on reviewing "Cleopatra" and not enjoying Elizabeth Taylor's performance
      Clip begins at: 12:35
    • Judith Crist on her appearances on Today
      Clip begins at: 00:00, Duration: 12m 35s
    • Judith Crist on her time as a film critic on Today
      Clip begins at: 21:34, Duration: 08m 30s
    • Judith Crist on interviewing Federico Fellini on Today
      Clip begins at: 20:30, Duration: 05m 43s

Professions

  • Hosts > Film Critic
    • Judith Crist on wanting to be a film critic
      Clip begins at: 27:19, Duration: 00m 42s
    • Judith Crist on her first attempt at becoming a film critic
      Clip begins at: 03:46, Duration: 06m 33s
    • Judith Crist on beginning to read movie reviews
      Clip begins at: 00:43, Duration: 01m 35s
    • Judith Crist on beginning to write film and television criticism
      Clip begins at: 03:31, Duration: 05m 10s
    • Judith Crist on Al Morgan inviting her to be movie critic for Today
      Clip begins at: 22:03, Duration: 06m 27s
    • Judith Crist on calling herself a journalistic reviewer
      Clip begins at: 08:53, Duration: 03m 45s
    • Judith Crist on interviewing Federico Fellini on Today
      Clip begins at: 20:30, Duration: 05m 43s
  • Hosts > Interviewer
    • Judith Crist on interviewing Federico Fellini on Today
      Clip begins at: 20:30, Duration: 05m 43s
SHARE THIS PAGE Bookmark and Share
Tweet

Submitted by Brian Perry on Fri, 2012-08-10 02:13.

I was saddened to learn of the death of Judith Crist at the age of 90. She was perhaps the first person to bring real film criticism to a mass audience and her pieces, be they positive or negative, were always a joy to read. The fact that she was the one critic feared most by the Hollywood community is a testament to her fearlessness honesty and integrity. One prominent producer once suggested that she be "burned at the stake for bitchcraft." She was not only a great critic but also one if the great ladies of 20th century American journalism. She will be missed.

Post new comment

  • Home
  • Interviews
  • About The Archive
  • Resources
  • News
  • Search
Academy of American Television
  • Home
  • The Interviews
  • Advanced Search
  • Blog
  • License Our Clips
  • Privacy Policy
  • Transcripts
  • Copyright Policy
  • Emmys.com
  • Emmysfoundation.org
  • About The Archive
© 1995-2013 Academy of Television Arts & Sciences Foundation All Rights Reserved Emmy and The Emmy Statuette are the trademark property of ATAS/NATAS
Site developed by FivePaths